Quick update to this. I noticed that my pickup was running crappy. This was using the same gas that I used in the LT just not mixed with oil of course. So I emptied some of the gas from the LT into a glass mason jar and let it sit for like 15 minutes or so, to find that my mixed fuel separated from a bunch of water. I then checked the gas that was still in my 5 gallon Jug to make sure it was not just the gas in the bike, and found the same thing.

Needless to say, I won't be buying gas from that station for anything in the future.